First Half Offensive Players Big Board
Here is the companion board for the defenders big board. This one goes to 70 as I had a harder time leaving some names off the list than I did for defenders.
This is not a draft board. For example, David DeCastro is ranked fourth because he’s got the fourth highest grade, well ahead of several good quarterback prospects like Matt Barkley and Landry Jones. But a team would be foolish to draft even the best guard in the league ahead of a pretty good quarterback supposing they need a quarterback. The positional value is highly disparate.
Take this board as a way of referencing the safest, most dynamic, or most talented offensive players in the class independent of positional value.
1.) Andrew Luck, QB, Stanford*
2.) Justin Blackmon, WR, Oklahoma State*
3.) Robert Griffin III, QB, Baylor*
4.) David DeCastro, OL, Stanford*
5.) Trent Richardson, RB, Alabama*
6.) Matt Kalil, OL, Southern California*
7.) Michael Floyd, WR, Notre Dame
8.) Alshon Jeffery, WR, South Carolina*
9.) Peter Konz, OL, Wisconsin*
10.) Matt Barkley, QB, Southern California *
11.) Landry Jones, QB, Oklahoma*
12.) Ryan Tannehill, QB, Texas A&M
13.) Jonathan Martin, OL, Stanford*
14.) David Wilson, RB, Virginia Tech*
15.) Lamar Miller, RB, Miami*
16.) Coby Fleener, TE, Stanford
17.) Riley Reiff, OL, Iowa*
18.) Mike Adams, OL, Ohio State
19.) Orson Charles, TE, Georgia*
20.) Dwayne Allen, TE, Clemson*
21.) Dwight Jones, WR, North Carolina
22.) Reuben Randle, WR, Louisiana State*
23.) Cordy Glenn, OL, Georgia
24.) Mike Brewster, OL, Ohio State
25.) Xavier Nixon, OL, Florida*
26.) Brandon Weeden, QB, Oklahoma State
27.) Kevin Zeitler, OL, Wisconsin
28.) Lucas Nix, OL, Pittsburgh
29.) Chris Polk, RB, Washington*
30.) Levy Adcock, OL, Oklahoma State
31.) Mohamed Sanu, WR, Rutgers*
32.) Ryan Broyles, WR, Oklahoma
33.) LaMichael James, RB, Oregon*
34.) Nick Toon, WR, Wisconsin
35.) Doug Martin, RB, Boise State
36.) Nate Potter, OL, Boise State
37.) Matt McCants, OL, Alabama-Birmingham
38.) Kelechi Osemele, OL, Iowa State
39.) Kendall Wright, WR, Baylor
40.) Jeff Fuller, WR, Texas A&M
41.) Nick Foles, QB, Arizona
42.) Kirk Cousins, QB, Michigan State
43.) Kellen Moore, QB, Boise State
44.) Michael Egnew, TE, Missouri
45.) Zebrie Saunders, OL, Florida State
46.) Andrew Datko, OL, Florida State
47.) Ryan Miller, OL, Colorado
48.) Matt Reynolds, OL, Brigham Young
49.) Isaiah Pead, RB, Cincinnati
50.) Bernard Pierce, RB, Temple*
51.) Juron Criner, WR, Arizona
52.) Marvin McNutt, WR, Iowa
53.) Markus Zusevics, OL, Iowa
54.) Senio Kelemte, OL, Washington
55.) Cyrus Gray, RB, Texas A&M
56.) Marquis Maize, WR, Alabama
57.) TY Hilton, WR, Florida International
58.) Jarius Wright, WR, Arkansas
59.) Jeff Demps, RB, Florida
60.) Brandon Mosley, OL, Auburn
61.) Ben Jones, OL, Georgia
62.) Jeff Allen, OL, Illinois
63.) A.J. Jenkins, WR, Illinois
64.) David Molk, OL, Michigan
65.) Devon Ramsey, RB, North Carolina
66.) Chad Diehl, RB, Clemson
67.) Deangelo Peterson, TE, Louisiana State
68.) Jermaine Kearse, WR, Washington
69.) Joe Adams, WR, Arkansas
70.) Greg Childs, WR, Arkansas
* Denotes an underclassman
First Half Defensive Players Big Board
We’re through the first half of the CFB season, meaning it’s time for a big board. This one will rank the defenders in the class 1-60. Why 60 you ask? I got tired after going that far.
Anyway, this set of rankings is not Redskins scheme-minded, I ranked the players according to what I thought their potential in to some general NFL schemes might be. Meaning, if Melvin Ingram can’t fit cleanly into a 3-4 but looks like an impact caliber 4-3 base end, then I’m not going to downgrade him. The player just needs to fit into some sort of popular NFL scheme.
I value production very high, but it can’t trump a legitimate physical flaw/defficiency if I see it. For example, it pained me to have to rank Cliff Harris and Jayron Hosley so low given their utterly phenomenal history of production so far. But I also can’t confidently project big things from them in the NFL given how thin-jointed and slender their builds are–they will be limited in the coverages and assignments they can play at the next level.
Some small regard is given to positional value in the rankings reminiscent of a draft board, so a pretty good corner will be ranked a little bit higher than a slightly better safety. The core consideration here is trying to project and measure future NFL impact.
Without further ado:
Here are my early defensive rankings:
1.) Luke Kuechly, LB, Boston College*
2.) Quinton Coples, DL, North Carolina
3.) Devon Still, DL, Penn State
4.) Dre Kirkpatrick, DB, Alabama*
5.) Morris Claiborne, DB, Louisianna State*
6.) Janoris Jenkins, DB, North Alabama
7.) Manti Te’o, LB, Notre Dame*
8.) Whitney Mercilus, DL, Illinois*
9.) Brandon Thompson, DL, Clemson
10.) Dont’a Hightower, LB, Alabama*
11.) Melvin Ingram, DL, South Carolina
12.) Vontaze Burfict, LB, Arizona State*
13.) Courtney Upshaw, LB, Alabama
14.) Kendall Reyes, DL, Connecticut
15.) Jonathan Banks, DB, Mississippi State*
16.) Travis Lewis, LB, Oklahoma
17.) LaVonte David, LB, Nebraska
18.) Zach Brown, LB, North Carolina
19.) Bruce Irvin, LB, West Virginia
20.) Ronnell Lewis, LB, Oklahoma*
21.) Brandon Jenkins, LB, Florida State*
22.) Vinny Curry, LB, Marshall
23.) Sean Porter, LB, Texas A&M*
24.) T.J. McDonald, DB, Southern California*
25.) Andre Branch, DL, Clemson
26.) Dontari Poe, DL, Memphis*
27.) Markelle Martin, DB, Oklahoma State
28.) Chase Minnifield, DB, Virginia
29.) Alfonzo Dennard, DB, Nebraska
30.) Billy Wynn, DL, Boise State
31.) Ray Ray Armstrong, DB, Miami*
32.) Cam Johnson, DL, Virginia
33.) Jayron Hosley, DB, Virginia Tech*
34.) Robert Lester, DB, Alabama*
35.) Alameda Ta’amu, DL, Washington
36.) Stephen Gilmore, DB, South Carolina*
37.) Jerel Worthy, DL, Michigan State*
38.) Josh Chapman, DL, Alabama
39.) Sean Spence, LB, Miami
40.) Coryell Judie, DB, Texas A&M
41.) Brandon Boykin, DB, Georgia
42.) Adrian Robinson, DL, Temple
43.) Donte Moss, DL, North Carolina*
44.) Shaun Prater, DB, Iowa
45.) Cliff Harris, DB, Oregon*
46.) Devin Taylor, DL, South Carolina*
47.) Mark Barron, DB, Alabama
48.) Audie Cole, LB, North Carolina State
49.) Omar Bolden, DB, Arizona State
50.) Donnie Fletcher, DB, Boston College
51.) Brandon Lindsey, LB, Pittsburgh
52.) Trevor Guyton, DL, California
53.) Jaye Howard, DL, Florida
54.) Kheeston Randall, DL, Texas
55.) Kenny Tate, LB, Maryland
56.) Alex Okafor, LB, Texas*
57.) Jerry Franklin, LB, Arkansas
58.) Malik Jackson, DL, Tennessee
59.) Emmanuel Acho, LB, Texas
60.) James Michael-Johnson, LB, Nevada
* denotes a junior prospect.
The Theory of Mike and Bruce’s Draft Gerontophilia
The other day I found myself talking with the contributors at the Extreme Skins draft thread and stumbled upon the fact that Mike and Bruce have not drafted a single underclassman with their 18 selections the past two drafts. That’s right, every one of their draft picks since they’ve come in to power has been a senior. This despite the fact that 2010 saw a record tying 53 early entrants (2008 also had 53) and 2011 established a new record 56 early entrants. In short, the two drafts that Allen and Shanahan have presided over had the largest group of early entrants to choose form in NFL history. By and large, most early entrants get drafted, and if the average draft class is about 255 players, then that means almost one in five players drafted is an underclassman.
Thus it’s peculiar that the front office has managed to make 18 selections without selecting a single one. That speaks to a trend and drafting preference on the part of Allen and Shanahan. Much has been said about their preference for drafting so many former team captains. Well it looks like we can add a new wrinkle to that theory: this front office also prefers drafting seniors.
But not just any seniors mind you. They need to be seniors with a long history of starts, and preferably lots of individual awards and statistical milestones on their resumes. For the positions that accumulate mainstream statistics, an Allen and Shanahan draft pick has ideally finished high on his school’s career lists.
– Terrence Austin produced the first and third ranked seasons for All Purpose yards in UCLA history in 2008 and 2009 with 1,878 and 1,818 respectively.
– Aldrick Robinson finished second in SMU history with 3,314 career receiving yards.
– Leonard Hankerson set Miami single season records for yards and touchdowns in 2010; he finished third in Miami history in receiving touchdowns (22) behind Michael Irvin and Lamar Thomas.
– Niles Paul ranks sixth in Nebraska history in receptions (102) and fifth in receiving yards (1,532).
– Roy Helu finished fourth on Nebraska’s career rushing list with 3,404 yards.
– Evan Royster is Penn State’s career rushing leader with an astonishing 3,932 yards and is distinguished as the only Penn State back to every rush for three consecutive 1,000 yard seasons. Wow.
These are some highly accomplished football players before they’ve even arrived at training camp.
But even the non-skill position draft picks came with a variety of accomplishments:
– Selvish Capers and Eric Cook were three year starters with over 30 starts each.
– Trent Williams started 39 of 50 games played at Oklahoma with plenty of awards and honors to put in his trophy case: two time first team All American from four different sources, two time first team All Big 12 selection, and a Freshman All American second team selection.
– Maurice Hurt only started 6 games in his career at Florida, but managed to play in 29 total as a dirty starter you just couldn’t keep off the field.
– Dennis Morris was a four year letterman that played in every game of his career, he was named an All American and All WAC performer in 2009.
– Ryan Kerrigan finished his career with more awards and achievements than can be listed, but some notable highlights are tying the FBS record for fumbles forced (14), finishing second in Purdue history in sacks (33.5) and fifth in tackles for loss (57), unanimous All American selection his senior year, second team All American his junior year, two time All Big Ten performer, and Big Ten Defensive Lineman of the Year and Big Ten Defensive Player of the Year in 2010.
– Jarvis Jenkins was a three year starter at Clemson with 37 career starts in 48 games played. A nifty little tidbit? He’s also Clemson’s career leader in blocked kicks.
– Perry Riley played in 42 games at LSU with 22 starts, won the Chick Fil-A Bowl Defensive MVP and was a finalist for the 2008 Butkus award.
– Brandyn Thompson was a three year starter for Boise State and two time All-WAC performer, winning the 2008 Fiesta Bowl Defensive MVP Award.
– Markus White was a top, award winning JUCO transfer to Florida State, where he finished his career as a two year starter.
– Dejon Gomes was a JUCO transfer that ended up playing 23 games at Nebraska as a key reserve, earning All Big 12 honorable mention in 2009.
– Chris Neild was a three year starter at West Virginia and was an All Big East selection his senior year.
So basically everyone the Redskins drafted in 2010 and 2011 has some individual awards on their shelves or several years of collegiate starts to look back on. What that means is that the prototypical Allen and Shanahan draft pick has been,
I didn’t even delve into all of the academic awards that some of our draft picks such as Ryan Kerrigan have won. Certainly that seems to be another factor that the front office considers and prefers. So add a fourth consideration,
to the list.
That’s not a bad set of criteria to draft by at all. It’s essentially the same one the Patriots seem to use and I think it’ll end up ensuring that most of these players will stick because they’ll be professional and they each have an established history of translating their talent and athletic ability into real production on the field. It seemingly limits the risk of picking busts.
One of the regular contributors suggested this method of only drafting productive senior prospects could be a temporary strategy adopted to build a solid foundation for their roster as they reshape the team in their image. Having largely completed this process by now, this fellow thought that the front office would start swinging on sketchier but talented prospects from the early entrant pool. There could certainly be something to this line of thought. But I think that Allen and Shanahan have demonstrated a clear preference for the type of players they like to draft with these past 18 picks. I think they’re bound to draft at least one junior player eventually because the odds of never doing so seem extremely remote. But I also wouldn’t bet on them picking an underclassman until they actually do it.
So if you’re trying to figure out who the Redskins will draft in this season’s class, perhaps it’s best to look away from the highly talented juniors who’d be early entrants like Matt Barkley, Landry Jones, and Andrew Luck. Instead look for the senior captains with those big career numbers and All Conference/Academic All Conference awards.